Earlier this year, I entered Cypress Walls into the 16th Annual International Self-Published Book Awards sponsored by Writer's Digest in the non-fiction category. I was hopeful that this might be an outlet to gain notoriety, but I was also grounded in the reality that there was a ton of competition and that literary judges are not exactly my core audience. The winners were notified in October and when no one called me with congratulations, I didn't think much more about it.
On Saturday, the mailman delivered a packet from F+W Publications which contained a standard rejection letter, a semi-lame "Certificate of Participation," an even lamer set of "Book Marketing and Promotion Tips," and a commentary sheet from the semi-mysterious Judge #40. The commentary proves that someone actually read my book and, honestly, made the $100 entry fee worth it. Here's the breakdown from Judge #40:
On a scale of 1 to 5 with 1 meaning "poor" and 5 meaning "excellent,"please evaluate the following:
Structure and organization: 2
Grammar: 4
Cover design: 3
I think a 9 out of 15 is respectable. Kudos to Gar and Kristin for their editing and proofing skillz and to Tyra for her artwork. I did find the lower score for structure and organization puzzling especially after I read that Judge #40 found "the writing clear and to the point." That was part of the answer to "What did you like best about this book?" The second half was "you make excellent use of sardonic humor."
Thank 'ya, Judge #40, thank 'ya very much. I'm glad you at least got a few laughs from Cypress Walls.
Now on the flip side, "How can the author improve this book?" Here's Judge #40's take: "The book is so self-involved it's a little off-putting. There are many, many unnecessary details."
I see Judge #40's point on the latter. Gar would have preferred if I had cut some of the more scatological scenes. Other readers have expressed similar opinions, but I kept the potty humor in mainly because my core audience is early twenty-somethings and it's a cold hard fact that young men of this age, especially, love potty humor. All right, all right. All men love potty humor.
All I can say to Judge #40 on the "self-involved" comment is that Cypress Walls is a memoir and that, well, memoirs are all about me, me, me. Plus, I would argue that at no point in your life are you as self-involved as you are in your early twenties.
After I submitted the materials to the contest, I realized there was a sub-category for "life stories." I didn't recall seeing that as I put the packet together and I can only wonder now how a different judge would have sized up Cypress Walls had he/she read it as a life story versus straight non-fiction. Considering how wildly subjective contests like these are, I doubt it would have made any difference. But, overall, the experience has left me encouraged heading into 2009.
Before wrapping up I wanted to give a quick shout out to Christian, a rep at my local CHASE bank. She helped me get a business checking account set up for JAF Publishing this morning. The first check from Barnes and Noble has finally been deposited!
May your time with family and friends over the next few days be blessed, travel safe and, as always, rock on.
Recent Comments